The President Donald Trump Tax Cuts & Corporations | The Last Word | MSNBC - YouTube

Channel: MSNBC

[8]
>>> WE HAVE OUR FIRST REPORT
[9]
>>> WE HAVE OUR FIRST REPORT CARD ON THE TRUMP TAX CUTS FOR
[11]
CARD ON THE TRUMP TAX CUTS FOR CORPORATIONS BELIEVE IT OR NOT.
[12]
CORPORATIONS BELIEVE IT OR NOT. IT HAS BEEN TWO YEARS SINCE
[15]
IT HAS BEEN TWO YEARS SINCE DONALD TRUMP SIGNED A TAX CUT
[17]
DONALD TRUMP SIGNED A TAX CUT PASSED BY THE REPUBLICAN
[18]
PASSED BY THE REPUBLICAN CONTROLLED CONGRESS INTO LAW,
[19]
CONTROLLED CONGRESS INTO LAW, WHICH CUT THE U.S. CORPORATE TAX
[21]
WHICH CUT THE U.S. CORPORATE TAX RATE FROM 35% TO 21%.
[23]
RATE FROM 35% TO 21%. BUT ACCORDING TO A NEW REPORT
[27]
BUT ACCORDING TO A NEW REPORT 379 OF AMERICA鈥橲 FORTUNE 500
[29]
379 OF AMERICA鈥橲 FORTUNE 500 COMPANIES ACTUALLY PAID ONLY A
[31]
COMPANIES ACTUALLY PAID ONLY A FEDERAL CORPORATE INCOME TAX
[32]
FEDERAL CORPORATE INCOME TAX RATE OF 11.3%.
[35]
RATE OF 11.3%. AND 91 OF AMERICA鈥橲 LARGEST
[39]
AND 91 OF AMERICA鈥橲 LARGEST CORPORATIONS LIKE AMAZON AND
[41]
CORPORATIONS LIKE AMAZON AND CHEVRON PAID NO FEDERAL INCOME
[42]
CHEVRON PAID NO FEDERAL INCOME TAXES AT ALL, ZERO, ZILCH.
[47]
TAXES AT ALL, ZERO, ZILCH. THIS IS ALL RECORDING TO A ANEW
[47]
THIS IS ALL RECORDING TO A ANEW REPORT FROM THE INSTITUTE OF
[49]
REPORT FROM THE INSTITUTE OF TAXATION ENTITLED CORPORATE TAX
[51]
TAXATION ENTITLED CORPORATE TAX AVOIDANCE IN THE FIRST YEAR OF
[52]
AVOIDANCE IN THE FIRST YEAR OF THE TRUMP TAX LAW.
[54]
THE TRUMP TAX LAW. BACK WITH US TO DISCUSS THIS IS
[57]
BACK WITH US TO DISCUSS THIS IS JOHN HARWOOD AND JOINING US ON
[60]
JOHN HARWOOD AND JOINING US ON THE PHONE A PULITZER PRIZEWINNER
[64]
THE PHONE A PULITZER PRIZEWINNER FOR "THE NEW YORK TIMES."
[65]
FOR "THE NEW YORK TIMES." WALK US THROUGH HOW THE TAX LAW,
[66]
WALK US THROUGH HOW THE TAX LAW, THE TRUMP TAX LAW MADE IT
[68]
THE TRUMP TAX LAW MADE IT POSSIBLE FOR AT LEAST 91
[71]
POSSIBLE FOR AT LEAST 91 COMPANIES OR 91 CORPORATIONS NOT
[73]
COMPANIES OR 91 CORPORATIONS NOT TO BE ABLE TO PAY A SINGLE PENNY
[75]
TO BE ABLE TO PAY A SINGLE PENNY IN FEDERAL INCOME TAX?
[76]
IN FEDERAL INCOME TAX? >> WELL, THE LAW DID A NUMBER OF
[79]
>> WELL, THE LAW DID A NUMBER OF THINGS.
[79]
THINGS. IT CUT THEIR TAX RATE BY 40%.
[82]
IT CUT THEIR TAX RATE BY 40%. YOU AND I DIDN鈥橳 GET ANYTHING
[83]
YOU AND I DIDN鈥橳 GET ANYTHING CLOSE TO 40% REDUCTION IN OUR
[87]
CLOSE TO 40% REDUCTION IN OUR TAX RATE.
[87]
TAX RATE. IT ALSO ALLOWED COMPANY TUESDAY
[91]
IT ALSO ALLOWED COMPANY TUESDAY IMMEDIATELY EXPENSE, THAT IS
[93]
IMMEDIATELY EXPENSE, THAT IS WRITE OFF THE COSTS, NOT
[96]
WRITE OFF THE COSTS, NOT EVERYBODY.
[96]
EVERYBODY. RESTAURANTS GOT LOST IN THE MIX.
[98]
RESTAURANTS GOT LOST IN THE MIX. BUT OVERALL YOU GOT TO QUICKLY
[100]
BUT OVERALL YOU GOT TO QUICKLY WRITE DOWN THE COSTS OF NEW
[102]
WRITE DOWN THE COSTS OF NEW INVESTMENTS AND FOR CAPITAL
[104]
INVESTMENTS AND FOR CAPITAL INTENSIVE COMPANIES LIKE OIL AND
[108]
INTENSIVE COMPANIES LIKE OIL AND MANUFACTURING BUYING NEW
[109]
MANUFACTURING BUYING NEW EQUIPMENT EVERY YEAR, IT CREATES
[110]
EQUIPMENT EVERY YEAR, IT CREATES A MUCH LOWER TAX BURDEN FOR THEM
[111]
A MUCH LOWER TAX BURDEN FOR THEM IN THE FUTURE.
[112]
IN THE FUTURE. AND WE NO LONGER TAX AMERICAN
[114]
AND WE NO LONGER TAX AMERICAN CORPORATIONS ON THE PROFITS THEY
[116]
CORPORATIONS ON THE PROFITS THEY EARN OVERSEAS AM.
[119]
EARN OVERSEAS AM. AND BECAUSE THE WAY THE LAW WAS
[120]
AND BECAUSE THE WAY THE LAW WAS DONE IT HAS ENCOURAGED COMPANIES
[122]
DONE IT HAS ENCOURAGED COMPANIES TO BUILD MORE OVERSEAS RATHER
[125]
TO BUILD MORE OVERSEAS RATHER THAN LESS IF THEY CAN FIND A TAX
[130]
THAN LESS IF THEY CAN FIND A TAX HAVEN TO HAVE TAX-FREE PROFITS
[134]
HAVEN TO HAVE TAX-FREE PROFITS OVERSEAS.
[134]
OVERSEAS. >> HAS THE PRESIDENT BEEN ABLE
[136]
>> HAS THE PRESIDENT BEEN ABLE TO SELL HIS ECONOMIC SUCCESS OR
[138]
TO SELL HIS ECONOMIC SUCCESS OR HIS ECONOMIC STIMULUS BASED ON
[141]
HIS ECONOMIC STIMULUS BASED ON HIS TAX LAW TO THE AVERAGE VOTER
[144]
HIS TAX LAW TO THE AVERAGE VOTER WHEN THEY鈥橰E NOT AS WE JUST
[145]
WHEN THEY鈥橰E NOT AS WE JUST POINTED OUT, CORPORATIONS ARE
[146]
POINTED OUT, CORPORATIONS ARE NOT PAYING THEIR FAIR SHARE,
[149]
NOT PAYING THEIR FAIR SHARE, THEY鈥橰E NOT PAYING ANY FEDERAL
[151]
THEY鈥橰E NOT PAYING ANY FEDERAL INCOME TAX AND SOMEHOW HE TOUTS
[154]
INCOME TAX AND SOMEHOW HE TOUTS THE ECONOMY IS DOING WELL?
[156]
THE ECONOMY IS DOING WELL? >> WELL, THE STRENGTH OF THE
[158]
>> WELL, THE STRENGTH OF THE COMPANY HELPS HIM SOMEWHAT, BUT
[161]
COMPANY HELPS HIM SOMEWHAT, BUT WE SAW IN THE 2018 ELECTIONS
[163]
WE SAW IN THE 2018 ELECTIONS THAT WAS NOT A POWERFUL WEAPON
[166]
THAT WAS NOT A POWERFUL WEAPON FOR REPUBLICANS TO PREVENT
[167]
FOR REPUBLICANS TO PREVENT DEMOCRATS FROM TAKING OVER THE
[168]
DEMOCRATS FROM TAKING OVER THE HOUSE.
[168]
HOUSE. AND THE REASON IS EVERYONE HAS
[171]
AND THE REASON IS EVERYONE HAS SEEN AND THEY SEE IT MORE NOW IN
[174]
SEEN AND THEY SEE IT MORE NOW IN 2019 THAN THEY DID IN 2018,
[176]
2019 THAN THEY DID IN 2018, DONALD TRUMP AND HIS AIDES MADE
[179]
DONALD TRUMP AND HIS AIDES MADE FOUR BASIC ASSERTIONS FOR THE
[180]
FOUR BASIC ASSERTIONS FOR THE TAX BILL.
[183]
TAX BILL. ONE WE HAD LAME 2% GROWTH HE WAS
[184]
ONE WE HAD LAME 2% GROWTH HE WAS GOING TO MAKE THE GROWTH RATE GO
[186]
GOING TO MAKE THE GROWTH RATE GO UP TO 3% OR MORE.
[188]
UP TO 3% OR MORE. IT WASN鈥橳 GOING TO INCREASE THE
[190]
IT WASN鈥橳 GOING TO INCREASE THE DEFICIT, IT鈥橲 GOING TO PUT A LOT
[191]
DEFICIT, IT鈥橲 GOING TO PUT A LOT OF MONEY IN THE HANDS OF THE
[193]
OF MONEY IN THE HANDS OF THE MIDDLE CLASS AND WASN鈥橳 GOING TO
[194]
MIDDLE CLASS AND WASN鈥橳 GOING TO PROVIDE A TAX CUT FOR THE RICH.
[196]
PROVIDE A TAX CUT FOR THE RICH. EVERYONE OF THOSE THINGS HAS
[197]
EVERYONE OF THOSE THINGS HAS TURNED OUT TO BE NONSENSE.
[199]
TURNED OUT TO BE NONSENSE. THE GROWTH RATE IS NOW BACK
[201]
THE GROWTH RATE IS NOW BACK AFTER A BRIEF PERIOD OF STIMULUS
[204]
AFTER A BRIEF PERIOD OF STIMULUS IN 2018, THE GROWTH RATE IS NOW
[205]
IN 2018, THE GROWTH RATE IS NOW BACK AT THE 2% LONG-TERM LEVEL
[208]
BACK AT THE 2% LONG-TERM LEVEL THAT HE INHERITED FROM PRESIDENT
[211]
THAT HE INHERITED FROM PRESIDENT OBAMA, THE DEFICIT鈥橲 GONE UP AND
[213]
OBAMA, THE DEFICIT鈥橲 GONE UP AND WE鈥橵E SEEN THAT CORPORATIONS
[215]
WE鈥橵E SEEN THAT CORPORATIONS HAVE SUBSTANTIALLY REDUCED THEIR
[217]
HAVE SUBSTANTIALLY REDUCED THEIR TAX BILL.
[219]
TAX BILL. THAT DOESN鈥橳 MEAN LOWERING THE
[220]
THAT DOESN鈥橳 MEAN LOWERING THE CORPORATE TAX RATE MAY NOT HAVE
[221]
CORPORATE TAX RATE MAY NOT HAVE BEEN HAD A HIGH RATE COMPARED TO
[223]
BEEN HAD A HIGH RATE COMPARED TO THE REST OF THE WORLD BUT, OF
[225]
THE REST OF THE WORLD BUT, OF COURSE, THEY DIDN鈥橳 CLOSE LOOP
[229]
COURSE, THEY DIDN鈥橳 CLOSE LOOP HOLES SUFFICIENT TO PAY FOR THAT
[231]
HOLES SUFFICIENT TO PAY FOR THAT FINANCE.
[231]
FINANCE. THAT鈥橲 WHY THE DEFICIT HAS GONE
[233]
THAT鈥橲 WHY THE DEFICIT HAS GONE UP SO MUCH.
[233]
UP SO MUCH. >> THE ARGUMENT THAT
[235]
>> THE ARGUMENT THAT REPUBLICANS, AND IN PARTICULAR
[236]
REPUBLICANS, AND IN PARTICULAR TRUMP, MADE WAS THAT IF WE
[238]
TRUMP, MADE WAS THAT IF WE REDUCE THE TAX BURDEN ON THESE
[240]
REDUCE THE TAX BURDEN ON THESE COMPANIES, THEY鈥橪L COME BACK AND
[241]
COMPANIES, THEY鈥橪L COME BACK AND INVEST IN AMERICA, HIRE MORE
[245]
INVEST IN AMERICA, HIRE MORE WORKER, MANUFACTURE MORE.
[246]
WORKER, MANUFACTURE MORE. THAT, IN TURN, PRODUCES MORE
[247]
THAT, IN TURN, PRODUCES MORE RESULTS FOR THE ECONOMY.
[249]
RESULTS FOR THE ECONOMY. HAVE YOU SEEN ANYTHING TO
[250]
HAVE YOU SEEN ANYTHING TO SUPPORT THAT OR SUBSTANTIATE
[252]
SUPPORT THAT OR SUBSTANTIATE THAT?
[253]
THAT? >> IT鈥橲 NOT IN THE DATA EITHER.
[254]
>> IT鈥橲 NOT IN THE DATA EITHER. A LOT OF THE MONEY COMPANIES
[256]
A LOT OF THE MONEY COMPANIES SAVE WAS USED TO BUY BACK STOCK,
[259]
SAVE WAS USED TO BUY BACK STOCK, WHICH INCREASES THE VALUE OF THE
[260]
WHICH INCREASES THE VALUE OF THE REMAINING SHARES AND STOCK
[262]
REMAINING SHARES AND STOCK OPTIONS FOR EXECUTIVES.
[263]
OPTIONS FOR EXECUTIVES. AND AYMAN, I DON鈥橳 THINK WE
[265]
AND AYMAN, I DON鈥橳 THINK WE SHOULD TALK ABOUT THIS AS A TAX
[268]
SHOULD TALK ABOUT THIS AS A TAX CUT BECAUSE WE鈥橰E BORROWING THE
[269]
CUT BECAUSE WE鈥橰E BORROWING THE MONEY TO PAY FOR THE SHORTFALL.
[271]
MONEY TO PAY FOR THE SHORTFALL. THIS IS SIMPLY A FUTURE TAX
[273]
THIS IS SIMPLY A FUTURE TAX INCREASE WITH INTEREST IN THE
[274]
INCREASE WITH INTEREST IN THE MEANTIME.
[275]
MEANTIME. IT鈥橲 NOT A TAX CUT.
[276]
IT鈥橲 NOT A TAX CUT. IT鈥橲 A TAX INCREASE THAT鈥橲 BEEN
[278]
IT鈥橲 A TAX INCREASE THAT鈥橲 BEEN DISGUISED TO MAKE YOU THINK IT鈥橲
[280]
DISGUISED TO MAKE YOU THINK IT鈥橲 A TAX CUT.