馃攳
Petrol Vs Electric Car (Nexon EV) | Cost Analysis | Konsi Kitni Sasti Hai ? - YouTube
Channel: Sarcastic Sindhi
[0]
Friends , electric vehicles can be the
next best thing for automobile industry,
[3]
and I feel like in the coming 10-15 years,
[6]
a lot of people who are driving petrol ,
diesel vehicles
[9]
will get converted to electric.
[11]
But at this date when I
plan of buying a vehicle then,
[14]
I think if I should buy
electric or petrol vehicle?
[18]
What are benefits and drawbacks?
how much money should I have to give
[21]
to electric or how much am I
saving by ultimately buying electric.
[25]
I tried to do a small cost
analysis and in this video,
[29]
I would be requiring your help
too , because your suggestion
[32]
will help the entire community
who are watching this video
[36]
Should they prefer electric for now?
[38]
or is it okay if they they
want to continue with petrol?
[42]
Let's start. My name is Chandan
and you're watching Sarcastic Sindhi.
[45]
let's get started.
[47]
Friends , to determine cost
[49]
or to make an analysis of the cost
[51]
a lot of things are variable.
[53]
There's no one variable but
instead there are so many things
[56]
that we don't know over the time
[58]
how much will change and how much not.
[60]
At a lot of places I have
taken the common value
[64]
and I've tried making
an analysis over that.
[65]
The value of these things might change
[68]
state to state , city to city
or even person to person.
[72]
At the last we'll try to get
the results accordingly,
[75]
for what it is good and for what it is not.
[78]
Let's start this comparison. If a
take a look at family car at today's rate
[82]
a good electric vehicle , which looks good
[85]
and which has good features. This
recalls me of a car called TATA NEXON.
[88]
If I have to buy one then probably
I'll be considering that for myself
[91]
at the moment with the options
being available at the market.
[94]
Now let's talk about cost.
[96]
If we are using petrol then how much
are we spending on it over a year?
[100]
and along with that what
is the running cost we get?
[103]
This is the first variable,
[105]
who's vehicle is running how much.
It is not necessary that
[107]
running of your vehicle and mine should be
same.
[109]
So here I'm taking a small common variable
[111]
1000 km/per month.
[112]
If you stay in a big city it might be less
[115]
and if you live in a small
city and your running is low
[118]
then maybe you might nit be able
to cover 1000 km in an entire month.
[122]
But I'll be taking the value
of 1000km to make a set bar.
[125]
With this , in one year
[127]
the vehicle's running is up to 12000km
[130]
Now the second variable is about average.
[132]
How much average is our vehicle giving?
[134]
This also differs on the
way we drive our car.
[138]
Company's claim that
[140]
results on road are less
and more on highways
[143]
there are too many variables.
[145]
So , I'll take the average here also,
[146]
15km/liter
[149]
that means if you buy
a car at this generation
[151]
then it'll give you so much of average.
[153]
If we want to run the vehicle for 12000km
[155]
and if the average of
the vehicle is 15km/liter
[157]
then it approximately
needs 800 liter of oil.
[159]
If we want to calculate the
cost of 800 liters of oil
[162]
in a year then approximately then
the petrol cost will come up to 68000/-
[166]
If the price of petrol is 85/-
[169]
It is today's rate but it keeps
on fluctuating and over the year
[173]
it differs a lot.
[175]
If we think it's not gong to fluctuate
much. but only 1/- here and there.
[179]
It keeps on fluctuating in
0.25 or 0.10 every now and then
[182]
So , the cost approximately is
[184]
about 68000/- or about
70000/- for an entire year for the fuel.
[190]
Let's compare the electronic vehicle here,
[194]
we were taking the example of Nexon.
[196]
The company is giving 30kwh
[198]
of battery's capacity.
[200]
The amount of energy it
needs to get from 0 to 100
[204]
is 30kw.
[205]
and the electricity company
from which we charge
[207]
in our house from where
the electricity comes
[210]
The unit that is charged there is also kwh.
[212]
This means 30 units
will be approximately
[215]
30 units of our electricity,
[217]
to get our car's battery
fully charged and
[220]
if we look at the unit cost
it also varies
[222]
from your city , your state.
[224]
Some get subsidy , some do not.
[227]
An average price will be around 6
[229]
but I'll take an upper value
[231]
of about 7/- per unit.
[234]
So , approximately electricity
of 210/- is being used.
[238]
Where as the company claims that car would
run up to 312km in that battery power.
[243]
But this 312km is also
the company鈥檚 own value.
[247]
But in result time the
result might come up to
[249]
will be around 275-280km in the city
[253]
and close to 300 if you're run on highway
[255]
because the region technology
has also been used there
[258]
which reproduces a lot of electricity
[261]
without giving extra
money for the electricity
[264]
So, if it runs 280km in 30 units then
[267]
to run 12000 km we have to,
[270]
we'll need up to 1286 units of electricity.
[273]
When I have taken the
electricity tariff zone as 7/-
[276]
if we multiply with that , then
approximately the cost will sum up to 9000/-
[280]
The result that we have got here is,
the yearly cost was
[283]
close to 70000/- but here
[286]
the yearly cost of fuel
that is the running cost
[289]
will be approximately 9000/-
[291]
for 12000km.
[292]
All this calculations are done for 1 year,
[295]
but if you buy vehicle
you'll not buy for 1 year.
[297]
If an average Indian user buys a car then
he'll have an ownership of minimum 8 years.
[302]
So let's take this to the level of 8 years,
[305]
if you're buying a new vehicle
and running it for 8 years then
[307]
what is the difference?
So in 8 years,
[310]
the biggest change will be
the cost variation in petrol.
[314]
The petrol price
increases on the daily basis
[317]
and is highly unstable
[319]
it can increase by 1/- in a
single night or even 2/- maybe
[322]
or 0.25 might drop too.
[323]
So approximately if we even take this as 10%
[326]
for the year on year growth
[327]
then a lot of difference might be there.
[329]
After 8 years from now,
if the petrol price is
[332]
highly unstable,
[334]
this involves a lot of factors , like
what is the price of global crude oil,
[338]
what are the terms of our
government with other nations?
[341]
How much of imports are taking
place and how much are not
[342]
a lot of factors depend of this.
[344]
But for an average
I'll take 100/- per liter
[348]
for 8 years, it can be
[350]
less than 100/- for the first 4 years
and more than 100/- for the next 4 years.
[353]
by accepting this condition,
[354]
this might be wrong. let me know what are
your opinion about this by commenting down.
[358]
So if take 100/- per liter then the
cost sums up to 80000/- for a year.
[362]
You'll have to spend 80000/-per year on
petrol if you're running a petrol vehicle.
[365]
If I am driving one or if I
want to buy a petrol vehicle
[368]
So , for 8 years with context to
80000/- year, it's close to 640000/-
[373]
If I'm not wrong.
[374]
You'll spend 640000/- for the petrol,
[377]
and if we see the same
thing in an electronic vehicle
[380]
the price of the electricity
[381]
will largely stay stable.
[383]
Because we don't
have to import like petrol.
[385]
In India a lot of electricity is
produced and hence it stays stable,
[390]
but still , if there's some growth
[393]
or the demand has increased
due to a lot of electronic vehicles
[396]
or the cost of production has increased,
or due to any other reason.
[400]
the cost of electricity is increased.
So approximately the 7/- we're taking ,
[404]
let's take average of 8 years as 9/-
[406]
and if we take 1286
units with an average of 9/-
[412]
which is comparatively more
for an average of 8 years.
[414]
If we multiply into 9/-
then it'll sum up to 11574/-
[419]
This is for 1 year and now
if we take it for 8 years then
[423]
it'll come around 93000.
[425]
There it was costing us 640000/-
[428]
for fuel cost , and here it is 93000/-
[431]
This means approximately
you can save up to 550000/-
[435]
if you're running the vehicle for 8 years.
[437]
And if all the variables that we have taken
[440]
approximately stays the same.
[442]
Now here , don't think that you
have earned or saved 55000/-
[447]
The twist here is that electronic vehicles
[450]
are much expensive than the
petrol vehicles for time being.
[454]
To neutralize features,
[456]
if we try to keep both the
models at the same level then,
[459]
The company that is giving the
automatic vehicle鈥檚 base variant
[462]
is about 844/-
[464]
But on the other hand , the price of
the electronics is close to 14 lakhs
[469]
but , here's a twist that
[470]
that the government is subsidizing.
[472]
that means , the road tax around
1.5 lakhs and all those other taxes
[477]
are been subsidizing and in 3 years
you'll be able to claim back 50000/- each
[480]
which we have paid in term of tax.
[484]
So the difference that
we have got here is,
[486]
we'll have to pay around 15lakhs
in the case of electronic vehicle
[489]
and around 10lakhs for
a petrol automatic vehicle.
[493]
So, the difference that
we've got is about 5 lakhs
[496]
this might differ , since I have
taken easy amounts for the calculation
[500]
so that we get an approximate value.
[503]
In the start you're
paying 5 lakhs extra but
[505]
but the same 5 lakh we had
saved in electronic vehicle
[508]
if we would have used
the vehicle for 8 years.
[510]
This means pay 5 lakhs now,
[513]
and slowly start to recover
5 lakhs of your money in 8 years.
[519]
If you're running is 12000km and
[522]
if petrol price grows in the
same way like we expected.
[526]
There are so many things
about electronic vehicles that
[530]
we have to consider if we are
planning to buy an electronic vehicle.
[533]
The first thing is , this is not hybrid
[535]
this does not have a petrol tank.
If you鈥檙e thinking about long tours
[538]
then it does not have so
much of stability as of now.
[542]
Because the charging points
that have been used in this
[544]
and the charging networks that are used are
[546]
very less in India.
[548]
There are so many cities where electronic
vehicles have not been launched yet
[552]
that means there are
no charging stations also,
[555]
so you can't take this for many routes.
[558]
The range is also very limited. if you're
driving around 280-300km on highway
[563]
then this is not enough for long runs.
[565]
If you travel intercity everyday,
[568]
if you stay in NCR or in Bengaluru
and your daily commute
[573]
is like you have to travel
50-100km up and down daily.
[577]
Then in that case electronic
vehicle is a good option here.
[580]
There's also a difference
that , in petrol vehicles
[583]
we get at least 1 service done every year.
[585]
and the major cost there
is of engine oil , air filter and
[590]
of part plugs too. All these things
does not exist in electronic vehicle
[593]
Because there's no engine
in that , it run with a motor in it.
[596]
So, the cost of every year that
[599]
labor would be used for
servicing , marinating , checking
[604]
and the service cost will be added but
[605]
the money of parts will be saved.
[608]
If you'd take the parts even
of 2000-3000 every year
[612]
which has to be put for
the vehicle鈥檚 service then
[615]
you'd be able to save 25000 inn this also.
[618]
But there are a lot of
complication in an electronic vehicle,
[621]
the battery pack is
the life of the vehicle.
[624]
Warranty of 8 years have
been given over these batteries.
[627]
If there's some problem in the battery for
8 years then the company will look over it.
[630]
But after 8 years if something
goes wrong with the battery then
[634]
then the cost that has
been told by the company.
[637]
Battery replacement
cost can be over 1 lakhs,
[642]
This the cost of today,
[644]
If it gets defective after 8 years then
it the cost might even go up to 2 lakhs.
[650]
Or there's a possibility of
applying the technology's rule which says
[653]
the more people use ,
the less the price becomes.
[658]
There's so much of mass production done.
[660]
We cannot say anything about
[662]
how much the battery price will be.
[664]
You are safe for 8 years
, there's no need to worry
[668]
If you're thinking for the small term,
[670]
that you'll use the vehicle
for 5-6 years and then sell it
[672]
then it's fine. But if you're
an long duration consumer
[675]
and if you want to use it for 10-12
years and not think about selling.
[677]
Then you've to consider that,
if the battery gets defective
[681]
then the price an sum way too much.
[683]
If we talk about TESLA. There's
a news that it's coming to India.
[687]
The battery pack that is used in TESLA,
[689]
is the same lithium pack.
[692]
I mentioned lithium because
[694]
India has to import lithium from
China since it has big mines of lithium.
[700]
This makes the cost more expensive.
[703]
Because of which there
a TESLA plant in China.
[706]
But in India , people from IIT
[708]
made fuel and technology
which is really affordable
[712]
and there's no charging time.
[714]
The big things is , we
charge the vehicle over night
[717]
it take 8 hours in home charger
[719]
and in case if we want to fast charge
it , then we are supposed to go to market
[722]
and pay them a bit or
[724]
you might even get some free services at
start if you get along the network of car.
[727]
There are franchise companies in UK
[730]
and they have a wide range of
charging stations at many places
[733]
they have made fast
chargers for the vehicles
[736]
and they have also made
membership schemes
[738]
if you pay them some monthly and yearly
[741]
you'll either get some
charges or unlimited recharge.
[744]
Such concepts can be seen in India soon.
[749]
We'll also get to see
many charging companies
[752]
who have their network at many places.
[754]
Even on highways we'll get to
see free charging from this network.
[759]
These are the concepts
[760]
But I'm looking at fuels and technology
[763]
which is going to start
it's trial in India very soon,
[765]
which is made by our
homegrown Indian IIT students.
[768]
Basically that doesn鈥檛
have any charging time,
[771]
and it's not even that expensive
while replacing the battery.
[775]
There's no charging time.
[777]
It charges the vehicle in 5 minutes and
you don't have to worry for 300-400 km
[783]
Finally , the results that have come out
[785]
with the current circumstances,
I won't be preferring Ev
[788]
Because I'll be going on long runs too.
[790]
The routes I take , I think there won't
be charging facility in any time soon
[795]
and in the long routes that I'm going,
[797]
if there's no charging then
what's the use of taking an EV?
[800]
What if it goes and just stops there?
[802]
Or what if I'm not able
to take it from here.
[803]
If I look at the cost , that is 5 lakhs
[806]
is almost the same.
[808]
I'm investing at first and then recovering
it or I'm paying slowly paying it later on.
[812]
I've got an idea in my mind,
[814]
why don't I keep my safest investment
that 5 lakhs in my bank or as FD
[819]
I'll get 30000-35000/- in a year
[821]
and I can use that money for petrol
[823]
or also for the service of the vehicle.
[825]
After all petrol vehicles have
already been tested at the market
[829]
the resales are very good but
[831]
here if we look at the environment
then obviously EV is a very good option
[835]
Carbon emissions are close
to zero in an electronic vehicles.
[838]
and there's another common logic is that
[841]
Your 5 lakhs in the
bank will stay as 5 lakhs,
[843]
and you're just using the interest
[845]
for the fuel but if you had
invested in vehicle then
[848]
it is an depreciating asset.
[850]
Every year it'll make the
value go near to zero.
[853]
Over the time if Fuels and
Technologies comes in India then imagine
[858]
how less the cost will be
[860]
in batteries because currently
we have to import them from china.
[864]
If it's home grown then,
[865]
the cost will reduce and with
that it'll be easy to go also.
[869]
the recharging system of 8 hours at
home for the vehicle to be fully charged
[874]
we'll be relieved from that.
[876]
Give me your suggestion by commenting.
what's your opinion?
[879]
Are you in favour of electronic vehicles?
[882]
Even I'm in favour in terms
of environment friendliness
[885]
But are you in favour of investing more
at first and then slowly recovering it?
[890]
Or you'd like to pay less and use
the rest as per your convenience.
[894]
Considering in today鈥檚 circumstances,
[896]
for EV , India is fully ready for Ev but
[900]
infrastructure has not been
fully deployed in entire India.
[904]
This is it for today鈥檚 video.
[906]
If you like the video and
got a bit of value then,
[908]
press the like button , subscribe the
channel and turn on the notification
[911]
if you like such internal
related videos.
[913]
I'll meet you in the next video.
My name is Chandan.
[915]
you're watching Sarcastic
Sindhi until next time. Stay safe!
[917]
Stay Sarcastic!
[919]
See ya!
Most Recent Videos:
You can go back to the homepage right here: Homepage