Shady Things Sam's Club Doesn't Want You To Know - YouTube

Channel: Mashed

[0]
There's a reason so many consumers are willing to spend their hard-earned money on an annual
[4]
membership fee to Sam's Club: The warehouse chain has some amazing deals on great products.
[8]
But whether you're a member or thinking about becoming one, there's a few things you should
[12]
know about Sam's Club.
[14]
In January 2018, Walmart announced that they would be closing 63 Sam's Club stores nationwide
[19]
and turning them into fulfillment centers for online orders.
[22]
"So the store actually's going out of business?"
[25]
"Really?"
[26]
"And they didn't say nothing?
[27]
It wasn't even on the news?"
[30]
According to CBS News, CEO John Furner said:
[33]
"We know this is difficult news for our associates, and we are working to place as many of them
[37]
as possible at nearby locations."
[39]
A controversy erupted over the thousands of employees that had been unceremoniously laid
[43]
off.
[44]
The announcement came on the exact same day that Walmart announced it would be raising
[47]
its minimum wage to $11 per hour.
[49]
"I'm going back home now.
[51]
I see that they're closed.
[53]
Mmnn!
[53]
Without any kind of warning or notice or anything.
[56]
They could have at least let us know."
[58]
According to the Washington Examiner, the company had also announced that they would
[62]
be giving employees up to $1000 in bonuses because of new tax cuts.
[66]
Business Insider reported that most of the laid-off employees weren't even aware of what
[70]
was happening until they showed up for work that day.
[72]
Some learned of the store closings because of signs on the locked doors.
[75]
Clearly, a lot of people felt the store closings were handled poorly, and it's hard to disagree.
[80]
"This store… this store is closed?"
[81]
"Permanently closed!
[82]
The whole store!"
[84]
"Oh my gosh."
[86]
"A former transgender employee claims her coworkers and managers harassed her over her
[90]
gender identity."
[92]
In 2017, Sam's Club was sued for discriminating against a transgender employee, and the case
[97]
attracted a lot of attention.
[98]
According to the Chicago Tribune, Charlene Bost claimed her coworkers had been calling
[102]
her names like "it" and "thing."
[104]
Bost said she was repeatedly harassed by her direct supervisor, who reportedly called her
[109]
"it" in front of other employees and took part in unwanted physical contact, along with
[113]
writing fake infractions against Bost that led to her being fired.
[116]
Bost asked for unspecified monetary damages and wanted the court to order Sam's Club to
[121]
train employees in order to prevent future harassment of other transgender employees.
[125]
In 2015, former Sam's Club CEO Rosalind Brewer, the first woman and first African-American
[131]
to lead a division within Walmart, came under fire for comments that some perceived as prejudice
[135]
against white men, if you can believe it.
[137]
In a 2015 interview with CNN, Brewer discussed the diversity of her team:
[141]
"Even with myself, I have to live it also.
[144]
My executive team is very diverse, and I make that a priority."
[150]
Brewer added that diversity, or lack thereof, was something she often had to discuss with
[153]
her suppliers:
[154]
"Just today we met with a supplier, and the entire other side of the table was all Caucasian
[160]
male.
[161]
That was interesting."
[162]
She added that she didn't want to talk at that meeting since there were no females present,
[166]
and claimed that she was, quote, "going to place a call" to the supplier about it.
[169]
Her comments immediately received an outlandish backlash on social media, with people obnoxiously
[174]
calling Brewer "racist" and using the hashtag #BoycottRacistSamsClub to rally supporters.
[180]
Meanwhile, plenty of people were disgusted by the campaign.
[183]
In a statement, Walmart President and CEO Doug McMillon fully supported Brewer:
[188]
"Roz was simply trying to reiterate that we believe diverse and inclusive teams make for
[193]
a stronger business.
[194]
That's all there is to it…."
[196]
Like most warehouse stores, Sam's Club is known for selling brand-name items at significantly
[199]
lower prices than the competition.
[201]
"You can see three quarters of our incremental sales already this year have come from those
[206]
new, better-for-you items.
[207]
You're gonna love that product."
[208]
"Thanks."
[209]
"You bet.
[210]
And I'll tell you what..."
[211]
But as it turns out, they reportedly haven't always had permission to sell the goods they
[215]
advertise.
[216]
One example is when the bicycle company Trek publicly expressed their shock at its bikes
[220]
being sold at the warehouse.
[221]
In 2016, Sam's Club listed some men's and women's Trek mountain bikes on its website.
[226]
The bikes were only available online... for $100 less than the prices on Trek's official
[231]
website.
[232]
A Trek spokesman told BRAIN that Sam's Club, quote, "did not acquire them from Trek directly"
[236]
and said they were investigating how the warehouse club had gotten the bikes.
[239]
He added:
[240]
"Trek has no plans to sell bikes at Sam's Club or any other big box retailer."
[244]
There was a similar issue with designer brand Fendi in 2006.
[248]
CNN Money reports that the brand sued Sam's Club for selling knock-off handbags, wallets,
[253]
and key chains at its stores, writing that:
[255]
"Walmart does not have a purchasing agreement with Fendi or anyone affiliated with the company."
[260]
The bags were being sold at significantly discounted prices, as low as two-hundred and
[264]
ninety-five dollars in some cases.
[265]
Meanwhile, Fendi claimed that the original version would retail for nine-hundred and
[269]
twenty-five dollars.
[270]
A spokesman defended Walmart in a statement, writing:
[273]
"... the company policy prohibits the retailer from selling knock-offs..."
[277]
Sam's Club stores each feature a sprawling pharmacy section, which has proven to be quite
[281]
convenient for shoppers.
[282]
But in 2018, the company got in some trouble with Medicaid.
[285]
According to a press release from the U.S. Attorney's Office for the District of Minnesota,
[289]
there was a complaint that both Walmart and Sam's Club pharmacies regularly enrolled Medical
[293]
Assistance beneficiaries in the companies' auto-refill program and then billed Medicaid
[298]
for prescriptions.
[299]
This was a violation of state rules and regulations, as Minnesota doesn't allow pharmacies to automatically
[305]
refill prescriptions paid for by the state's Medicaid program without an explicit request
[309]
from the beneficiary.
[310]
Allegedly, employees at the pharmacy were the first people to report this violation
[314]
to the company managers, but even after they did, Walmart and Sam's Club kept automatically
[319]
refilling prescriptions.
[320]
In the end, Walmart Stores, Inc. and Sam's West, Inc. agreed to pay a total of eight-hundred
[324]
and twenty-five thousand dollars to resolve False Claims violations.
[329]
The way that Sam's Club treats employees has reportedly stirred up quite a bit of controversy
[332]
over the years, as evidenced by two separate lawsuits.
[335]
In 2002, The New York Times reported a class-action lawsuit, as well as individual lawsuits, against
[340]
Walmart and Sam's Clubs across twenty-eight states.
[343]
The controversy stemmed from the company allegedly refusing to pay employees for work they performed
[348]
off-the-clock.
[349]
One former employee, Verette Richardson, claimed that she sometimes worked for up to three
[353]
hours without getting paid, saying:
[355]
"They wanted us to do a lot of work for no pay.
[357]
A company that makes billions of dollars doesn't have to do that."
[360]
In response, a Walmart spokesman said:
[362]
"Off-the-clock work is an infrequent and isolated problem, which we correct whenever we become
[367]
aware of it."
[368]
Unfortunately, there have been other similar lawsuits since then.
[371]
According to NBC, a California jury awarded Walmart workers one-hundred and seventy-two
[375]
million dollars for illegally denied lunch breaks in 2006, while they settled a similar
[380]
case in Colorado for fifty million dollars.
[383]
That same year, a judge approved a class-action lawsuit against Walmart Stores Inc. by employees
[387]
in Pennsylvania who said they were pressured to work off-the-clock.
[390]
And in 2018, Class Action reported a lawsuit against Walmart and Sam's Club that claimed:
[396]
"... employees have ended up performing pre- and post-shift off-the-clock work without
[399]
being paid commensurate wages, including time-and-a-half overtime pay."
[404]
"Want some cookies to go with that milk?
[406]
Sam's Club charges $19.98 for a five-pound tub of chocolate chip bakery cookies.
[411]
Costco charges $15.55!"
[414]
The allure of shopping at a place like Sam's Club isn't just buying food in bulk, it's
[418]
mainly about saving money on necessary household items.
[420]
But the value of the products that Sam's Club sells has raised a lot of questions.
[424]
A 2016 Fox Business report claimed that you might not be saving quite as much as you think
[429]
with your trusty Sam's Club membership.
[431]
The report points out that prices are indeed lower at a place like Sam's Club when compared
[435]
to a store like BJ's or traditional grocery stores.
[438]
But Michael Clayman, editor and writer at Warehouse Club Focus, told The Motley Fool
[442]
that the results of price reporting,
[444]
"... show the dramatic savings a consumer receives by shopping at a club compared to
[447]
the other two."
[448]
But here's the thing: It's not just about price.
[451]
Billie Blair, an organizational psychologist and CEO of Change Strategists, Inc., pointed
[456]
out the added cost of what he calls "wastage from overbuying," noting:
[460]
"Warehouse clubs almost never save money for the individual shopper."
[463]
Basically, if you're habitually throwing away food because you bought too much of it, plus
[467]
paying an annual fee, you probably aren't really saving anything.
[470]
Sure, if you shop smart by buying only what you need and will use, then you have the potential
[475]
to save, otherwise, you're more-or-less out of luck.
[479]
It may have been proven that prices at Sam's Club are on the lower end of the spectrum
[482]
when it comes to other big box retailers and grocery stores, but that doesn't mean that
[485]
everything is a great buy.
[487]
Experts told Market Watch that some items like car parts, medication, and alcohol are
[491]
almost always a good deal, but plenty of other items aren't worth buying in bulk.
[495]
"Your credit card called.
[496]
They want to make sure you're the one buying cream soda in bulk.
[499]
"I sure am."
[500]
According to experts, books, CDs, and DVDs can be found cheaper on Amazon.
[504]
Jon Lal, CEO and founder of Be Frugal, said to avoid buying food perishables, such as
[509]
condiments like mayo.
[511]
That's because those bulk items will probably go bad since there's really no way to consume
[515]
them in time.... no matter how much you pour into your dinner.
[517]
"Let's just let this all come together, bind together, that's sort of the virtue of mayonnaise!"
[523]
Erin Konrad, a spokesperson for Coupon Pal, said that diapers can be found cheaper at
[527]
places like Target and Amazon.
[529]
"Whoa, we get new diaps?
[530]
Easy on the lumbar there, sport."
[533]
Matthew Ong , the retail analyst for NerdWallet, told Market Watch that laundry detergent in
[538]
bulk can lose its efficacy quickly, meaning you'll probably waste money because you won't
[542]
be able to use all the detergent in time.
[544]
Lastly, Konrad and Ong agreed that paper goods like toilet paper and tissues can be found
[548]
cheaper at Target or grocery stores with coupons.
[551]
One of Sam's Club's biggest competitors is Costco, another big box retailer known for
[555]
great prices and for treating its employees very well.
[558]
Costco has been praised for excellent wages and benefits, and it seems that Sam's Club
[562]
simply can't compare.
[563]
In 2008, Slate reported that Sam's Club employees made a starting wage of ten dollars an hour
[567]
and made twelve dollars and fifty cents after four and a half years.
[571]
Meanwhile, a new Costco employee started at eleven dollars an hour, made nineteen dollars
[575]
and fifty cents per hour after working there for four and a half years, and received a
[578]
bonus of over two-thousand dollars every six months.
[581]
There are a few reasons for this.
[583]
According to Slate, Costco sells pricier items than Walmart and Sam's Club.
[587]
Costco employees can also be members of the Teamster's union, but not Walmart employees.
[592]
So why doesn't Sam's Club offer the same wages?
[594]
Tim Worstall at Forbes believes it may do more harm than good:
[597]
"[About] seven hundred thousand people would lose their jobs at Walmart.
[601]
Which is, I think you'll agree, a fairly large result…"
[604]
In 2014, Sam's Club was slapped with a class-action lawsuit over its freshness guarantee.
[609]
A South Carolina customer claimed that Sam's Club had repeatedly violated the language
[613]
of that promise, which said customers were entitled to a,
[616]
"... 200% money-back guarantee on all fresh meat, seafood, bakery and produce.
[621]
Non-Members receive 100% money-back guarantee."
[624]
The disgruntled customer claimed that she'd returned a significant amount of, quote, "fresh
[628]
meat, bakery, and produce items" over the years.
[630]
She insisted that she'd never been refunded more than the purchase price of an item, nor
[634]
was she offered the return purchase plus a replacement product.
[637]
The lawsuit claimed:
[638]
"Sam's has failed to honor the 200% Freshness Guarantee for many thousands, if not millions,
[643]
of its members."
[644]
According to Top Class Actions, the class action settlement resolved this claim in 2018,
[648]
along with a similar but separate case filed in California, with Sam's Club offering a
[652]
$6 million settlement fund.
[655]
Check out one of our newest videos right here!
[657]
Plus, even more Mashed videos about your favorite stuff is coming soon.
[660]
Subscribe to our YouTube channel and hit the bell so you don't miss a single one.