Data Brokers Have Millions of Workers' Paystubs; See If They Have Yours - YouTube

Channel: NBC Bay Area

[0]
well who sees your pay sub each payday
[2]
just you your boss the irs and a data
[4]
broker a data broker that's the issue
[7]
there is a good chance that a private
[9]
data company is getting to see your pay
[11]
stub too but why consumer investigator
[14]
chris kimura has been asking how why and
[17]
what can you do about it
[19]
what we're about to explain is likely
[21]
surprising and new to you but it's
[23]
probably not at all new to the execs in
[25]
your company and it's growing fast
[28]
look online we share who we love what we
[31]
eat where we travel but not how much we
[35]
make talking about one's salary is
[38]
really not common practice and never has
[40]
been san francisco etiquette expert lisa
[42]
misragrat says it's proper to keep your
[44]
paycheck private your salary is between
[47]
you your boss and your family period
[51]
well not anymore it's mind-blowing and
[53]
people have no idea that's john weinberg
[56]
i'm a law professor at wayne state
[58]
university in detroit and one of the
[60]
things i pay attention to is privacy and
[62]
databases professor weinberg and i
[64]
discussed the work number a company that
[67]
says it has payroll records on more than
[69]
half the country's workforce so where
[72]
does the work number get all those pay
[73]
stubs it says more than 2 million
[76]
employers hand over their workers
[79]
payroll data every pay period as a way
[81]
to outsource the headache of verifying
[83]
employment and pay
[86]
the credit report company equifax owns
[88]
the work number for
[90]
54.95
[91]
it'll verify a person's employment and
[93]
provide their pay history
[96]
equifax says the federal fair credit
[98]
reporting act dictates who's authorized
[100]
for access equifax says it only lets in
[102]
people who say they are verifiers people
[104]
like landlords bank officers hr and such
[107]
who want to check your employment or
[109]
income but folks like debt collectors
[111]
can buy a report too
[113]
weinberg sees trouble equifax has not
[116]
historically been real good about data
[119]
security
[120]
about making sure that only the people
[121]
who are supposed to see the information
[123]
actually see it the fbi said chinese
[126]
intelligence breached equifax in 2017
[129]
and compromised more than 150 million
[132]
americans credit reports we asked
[134]
equifax about the work numbers security
[137]
it declined an interview but sent us a
[139]
statement saying it takes data
[140]
stewardship very seriously and random
[143]
audits weed out people who lie to access
[146]
its trove of half a billion pay records
[148]
i really question the usefulness of
[150]
having all this data hayley tuskayama is
[152]
with the electronic frontier foundation
[154]
which advocates for civil liberties
[156]
including privacy tuskayama has concerns
[159]
about employers forking over employees
[161]
private pay data she wonders whether
[163]
workers have any idea what's going on if
[165]
employers are doing this without
[167]
employee consent then i think it
[169]
shouldn't be happening the work number
[171]
is not alone
[173]
in san francisco there's true work its
[175]
website says users can instantly access
[177]
more than 35 million workers payroll
[180]
data true work did not respond to us so
[183]
why are so many companies sharing their
[185]
employees private payroll info we ask
[188]
walmart because it employs more people
[190]
than any other company and its website
[192]
indicates it uses the work number we did
[194]
not get a response next we asked three
[196]
big business lobbying groups also no
[199]
response then that really calls into
[201]
question you know why they believed it
[204]
was a good idea at all or if they even
[206]
thought through it equifax says the two
[208]
million companies that share payroll
[209]
data win because sharing it saves them
[212]
time and money outsourcing employment
[214]
verification then employees win getting
[217]
quicker loan decisions is getting a
[219]
decision
[221]
a minute an hour or a day faster than
[225]
before worth having all of this payroll
[228]
information stored
[230]
for who knows how long in one place
[233]
so i definitely as a privacy advocate
[235]
would say no so what about opting
[237]
yourself out equifax said no well then
[240]
takayama says your boss should let you
[243]
decide whether to give your pay stubs to
[245]
data brokers employees should be able to
[247]
make the individual choice if you ask
[249]
your company to let you opt out lisa has
[252]
some etiquette for your conversation i
[254]
would be very upfront and frank with my
[256]
boss and say i really don't feel
[258]
comfortable about this can you please
[260]
remove me from the list
[262]
you are not powerless here right now you
[264]
can see if the data brokers have your
[266]
payroll data you can read through it
[268]
yourself you can check for errors
[270]
dispute them you can even lock down all
[273]
of your data all from the work number
[274]
website i just did it myself and to help
[277]
you we made a how-to video that runs
[279]
through every single step we've just
[282]
posted it to our website and our youtube
[284]
channel we're going to run it on tv
[286]
tomorrow too