Minimum wage debate: The arguments for and against raising it to $15 - YouTube

Channel: Washington Post

[1]
after 10 years of cold indifference we
[3]
have
[4]
raised the minimum wage for millions of
[6]
hard-working americans
[7]
the last time we saw the federal minimum
[9]
wage increase
[10]
justin bieber looked like this
[14]
so why are politicians cruising so
[16]
slowly toward raising the minimum wage
[18]
are we there yet no are we there yet no
[21]
bernie sanders thinks it's because
[23]
they've been paying more attention to
[24]
those deep pocketed business groups
[26]
walmart mcdonald's dollar tree wendy's
[28]
burger king uber subway dunkin donuts
[30]
home depot
[31]
and to those corporations that benefit
[32]
the most from low-wage workers
[34]
no one in america can live with dignity
[37]
can raise a family
[39]
on 11 or 12 dollars an hour and a whole
[41]
bunch of politicians
[43]
in both parties seem to be coming around
[45]
to the idea and we will persist
[47]
with the minimum wage we want to reward
[49]
hard-working people
[51]
i don't pay you to breathe you hardly
[53]
pay us at all
[54]
you have many republicans who represent
[58]
states where an increase in the minimum
[60]
wage has passed
[61]
by the voters that puts them in a very
[63]
difficult situation this is congressman
[65]
bobby scott
[66]
he introduced the raise the wage act of
[68]
2021. there's no county in the united
[70]
states for example
[72]
where a full-time minimum wage worker
[75]
can afford a modest two-bedroom
[77]
apartment not just a high-income areas
[80]
not a single county a full-time worker
[82]
and that's not right
[83]
if the u.s had kept up with inflation
[85]
minimum wage would be around 20
[87]
right now instead it sits at just 7.25
[91]
cents an hour
[92]
the bill also makes it so that we won't
[94]
go another decade without raising the
[96]
minimum wage
[97]
and this legislation increases the
[99]
minimum wage gradually to fifteen
[101]
dollars an hour by 2025
[103]
but then increases it with inflation so
[106]
that we don't have to
[107]
have these long gaps again still not
[109]
everyone is on board
[110]
we know the result
[114]
of a 15 federal minimum wage increase
[117]
all at once 1.4 million loss
[120]
jobs that's not what we need in the
[123]
middle
[123]
of a pandemic trying to do that big of a
[126]
jump
[127]
overnight is would be really tricky on
[130]
the economy
[130]
that's heidi sherholtz she's a senior
[132]
economist at the economic policy
[134]
institute
[135]
from the economic perspective we want
[138]
workers to get
[139]
higher wages as quickly as possible
[141]
while balancing
[143]
giving businesses time to adjust so if
[146]
you think
[146]
it's okay to have a 10 minimum wage we
[149]
don't even get there
[150]
this year in the last congress a
[153]
republican-led senate
[154]
didn't give much attention to the
[156]
federal minimum wage but in the new
[158]
congress house democrats have
[160]
already passed this bill but the senate
[162]
sucks the fun out of that real quick
[165]
miss cinema miss cinema no some said
[168]
they want to debate it as a freestanding
[169]
bill
[170]
other opponents say it'll cause job loss
[172]
or primarily benefit teenagers with
[174]
little experience who just want extra
[176]
spending money
[177]
welcome to gettyberg your home of the
[178]
good burger can i take your order
[181]
but that's not totally accurate
[182]
according to sureholds one in ten
[185]
workers who would get a raise is a
[187]
teenager people who would be affected by
[189]
this minimum wage increase
[191]
on average contribute half
[194]
of their household's total income these
[197]
jobs
[198]
deeply matter according to the
[200]
congressional budget office
[201]
raising the federal minimum wage to 15
[203]
an hour by 2025
[205]
would increase wages for at least 17
[207]
million people and lift almost 1 million
[209]
people out of poverty but
[211]
it would also put 1.4 million americans
[213]
out of work
[214]
is that outcome worth it we keep hearing
[217]
about the minimum wage either being
[219]
bad for small businesses or good for
[222]
workers and that seems to be the
[223]
parameters of the debate
[224]
this is colleen duty she's a history
[226]
professor at depaul university
[228]
and that ignores the fact that in 1938
[231]
when franklin roosevelt
[233]
and his administration introduced the
[236]
first
[236]
federal minimum wage legislation they
[239]
did so
[240]
as part of a stimulus package put a flaw
[244]
below which industrial wages shall not
[247]
fall
[250]
millions of industrial workers
[253]
receive pay so low that they have
[256]
little buying power people at the
[259]
bottom 20 of the wage earners spend more
[263]
of their
[263]
income than those at the top
[266]
who tend to save more of their income so
[269]
if we're thinking how do we stimulate
[270]
the economy
[271]
encouraging consumption by putting money
[273]
into the pockets of those people who are
[274]
then going to go out and buy
[275]
stuff is an effective strategy so if we
[278]
waited a decade
[279]
why now postcoded context is making
[282]
everyone really think about okay
[284]
what did we do in the aftermath of the
[286]
great recession one thing that we
[288]
learned in the aftermath of the great
[289]
recession
[290]
is that even if you get jobs back
[293]
it doesn't necessarily imply they're
[296]
good jobs it doesn't necessarily imply
[298]
that you are going to see strong wage
[299]
growth
[300]
and there's also a lot of investment in
[303]
having
[303]
the kind of recovery that's not just
[305]
strong but it's also equitable
[308]
and a higher minimum wage is a key part
[310]
of that