The Instagram aesthetic that made QAnon mainstream - YouTube

Channel: Vox

[0]
there's a certain look that's taken over
[2]
everything
[3]
a certain color palette kind of font and
[5]
design
[6]
today this visual style sells us meal
[9]
kits and underwear
[10]
and monthly toothbrush subscriptions and
[12]
just about everything else
[14]
but it's also showing up here in
[16]
seemingly harmless trendy instagram
[18]
posts about child trafficking
[21]
on instagram there are over 800 000
[23]
posts like this
[24]
from social media influencers and
[26]
regular users with the hashtag
[28]
save the children we've seen things like
[30]
this before
[31]
slideshows about social justice and
[33]
current events dominated instagram this
[35]
summer
[36]
but something else is happening here on
[38]
facebook membership in pages and groups
[40]
branded as anti-child trafficking
[42]
grew three thousand percent between july
[45]
and the end of september
[46]
by the end of august in-person rallies
[48]
started taking place in cities
[50]
across the world ending child
[52]
trafficking is
[53]
hardly controversial but behind that
[55]
surge in growth is the baseless
[57]
conspiracy theory known
[58]
as q anon now an ideology once confined
[61]
to the more obscure parts of the
[63]
internet
[63]
is finding its way mainstream one
[66]
instagram post
[67]
at a time
[79]
on october 28 2017 the first of a series
[83]
of posts from an anonymous user appeared
[85]
on the 4chan message board
[87]
paul the user was nicknamed q after q
[89]
level security clearance that's the
[91]
energy department equivalent of top
[93]
secret
[93]
the community that followed and believed
[95]
those anonymous postings became known as
[97]
q anon
[98]
and they developed an elaborate
[99]
conspiracy theory lore that president
[101]
trump is fighting a global trial
[102]
trafficking network
[104]
led by satanic cannibalistic left-wing
[106]
pedophile elites
[107]
their theories have been proven false
[109]
time and time again but that didn't stop
[111]
the community from spreading
[112]
from 4chan to another messaging board
[114]
8chan and to places like twitter
[117]
youtube and facebook and as it did the
[120]
posts
[120]
videos and memes explaining its ideology
[122]
became more accessible
[124]
and digestible now qnon is a giant
[127]
entanglement of conspiracy theories with
[129]
dozens of offshoots that invites all
[131]
different kinds of conspiratorial
[132]
thinking
[133]
into its fold kyoto has always been a
[136]
big tent conspiracy theory that invites
[138]
people of different beliefs
[140]
and the thing is because the q a
[141]
narrative is so broad
[143]
and sprawling people can kind of enter
[145]
it and pick out the the
[147]
things that they like the best that
[149]
paired with the facebook algorithm
[151]
which uh recommends like other groups
[153]
that someone might be interested in
[155]
that turns into a very uh dangerous
[157]
combination
[158]
the q anon follower blocked the hoover
[160]
dam with an armored vehicle
[162]
a far right conspiracy theorist was
[165]
planning a kidnapping and douglas
[167]
guy a 24 year old man was charged in the
[169]
shooting death of a reputed mob boss
[171]
his attorneys argued he was motivated by
[174]
q anon
[175]
in 2019 the fbi labeled hunon as a
[177]
potential domestic terror threat after
[179]
some q anon followers started committing
[181]
serious crimes in the real world
[183]
on facebook q anon related activity grew
[185]
steadily for years without consequences
[188]
but then something changed there is a
[190]
lot of evidence that suggests
[192]
that the pandemic had a big effect on
[194]
the growth of q anon the
[195]
the impact of people spending a lot more
[198]
time indoors
[199]
and being online a lot more combined
[202]
with the stress of the pandemic and the
[204]
uncertainty of the future
[206]
uh that was a toxic combination that
[208]
pushed people into q a
[211]
in march three leading q and on facebook
[213]
group saw their membership rise from
[215]
under fifty thousand to over three
[216]
hundred thousand
[218]
by august an internal investigation in
[220]
facebook reviewed by nbc
[222]
found that a number of qnon groups and
[224]
pages had more than
[225]
3 million followers on august 19th
[228]
facebook announced that it would be
[229]
banning hundreds of q on pages and
[231]
groups
[232]
and after that traffic for q and on
[234]
phrases and hashtags
[235]
fell but membership in groups posing as
[238]
anti-child trafficking groups exploded
[240]
and in those groups users were still
[242]
largely spreading q anon content
[245]
q anon followers had simply pivoted to a
[247]
new hashtag to improve their image
[249]
one that was already being used for a
[250]
fundraising campaign by a uk-based
[252]
charity save the children i suppose for
[255]
someone like me who's kind of been
[256]
covering q and on for the past number of
[258]
years
[259]
like the past six months have kind of
[260]
been you know it's kind of been like
[262]
watching a tsunami in slow motion
[263]
save the children is as i say it's a
[266]
simple rebrand of cubanon
[268]
it's a very simple and effective message
[270]
to bring the q on movement to a wider
[272]
audience
[274]
you know who doesn't want to save
[275]
children
[277]
it's hard to accurately trace how the
[279]
save the children hashtag jumped from
[281]
these cute on facebook groups
[283]
to mainstream accounts on instagram but
[285]
by july
[286]
high profile accounts like model helen
[288]
owen and the real housewives of orange
[290]
county's kelly dodd
[291]
boosted the hashtag with inaccurate or
[293]
misleading statistics
[295]
this coincided with the united nations
[297]
human trafficking awareness day
[299]
other accounts put together slideshow
[301]
style infographics
[302]
like these and these are all packaged up
[304]
in very pretty posts
[306]
that are you know essentially they're
[307]
very easily digestible especially to
[309]
people that are not familiar with q and
[310]
on
[310]
their their colors are so a lot softer
[313]
there's a lot of pastels and it's very
[315]
pretty and nice and and when if you look
[317]
at it without reading the words you
[319]
would think it would be
[320]
just like just any other kind of uh yoga
[322]
inspired um you know instagram post
[325]
and so the move to instagram kind of
[327]
brought you know it brought cuban on to
[329]
this kind of
[330]
lifestyle influencer circle really and
[333]
many of these influencers already
[334]
they already have very high followings
[336]
and they already have a dedicated
[337]
audience that will
[338]
you know very much listen to what they
[339]
have to say accounts that might
[341]
otherwise be getting just a few hundred
[342]
likes on posts
[343]
found themselves getting tens of
[345]
thousands of likes as soon as they
[346]
started posting about save the children
[348]
a lot of people who get into q a
[351]
especially if they're struggling
[352]
influencers
[353]
they notice that these q and themes
[355]
they're like an internet cheat code
[357]
because they attract people who are very
[360]
engaged they spend a lot of time online
[362]
and if you start promoting keyword on
[363]
themes you start noticing that you're
[365]
getting a lot more likes and shares
[367]
that could be a big incentive to keep
[369]
doing it
[371]
perhaps the most damaging part of the
[372]
save the children movement is how
[374]
inaccurate information is making it
[375]
harder to fight actual trafficking
[378]
one of these most often cited statistics
[380]
is that 800 000 children go missing
[382]
every year in the u.s
[384]
that number comes from a 2002 survey
[386]
that asked parents if they had reported
[388]
their children as runaways sometime in
[390]
the previous year
[391]
797 and 500 said that they had
[394]
the 2019 fbi data puts that number
[397]
closer to 421 000.
[399]
roughly half of those reports are
[401]
related to custody disputes
[403]
and the rest mostly relate to runaways
[405]
but even then that number refers to
[407]
children who are reported missing by
[408]
their parents
[409]
the vast majority of whom over 99
[411]
percent return home within hours or days
[414]
in that 2002 study only 115 were
[417]
considered stereotypical kidnappings
[419]
there's no reliable data on how many
[421]
people are trafficked in the u.s
[423]
each year but stereotypical kidnappings
[425]
aren't what trafficking usually looks
[427]
like
[427]
instead it often takes the form of
[429]
forced labor or wage theft
[430]
most commonly in agriculture domestic
[432]
work or sex work
[434]
and the people most at risk are those
[435]
already vulnerable youth experiencing
[437]
homelessness
[438]
in foster care or unstable housing lgbtq
[441]
plus youth who have been kicked out of
[443]
their homes
[443]
or migrant young people most people kind
[446]
of have this idea in their head that
[447]
it's you know children being lifted off
[449]
the streets
[449]
and been shipped overseas you know and
[451]
you know all of that that does happen
[453]
it doesn't happen at all to the extent
[455]
that you and unfollowers believe that it
[456]
does
[457]
but the hysteria caused by distorted
[459]
numbers has led to a deluge of calls and
[461]
outreach from concerned q anon followers
[463]
and it's overwhelming the organizations
[465]
fighting actual child trafficking
[467]
and that's very damaging because it made
[469]
it harder for people with real
[470]
information about possible human
[472]
trafficking victims
[473]
to get through and so we've seen this
[476]
actually repeatedly the ways in which
[477]
the misinformation
[479]
that this that this kind of save the
[480]
children style of q anon
[482]
is uh is promoting damages real efforts
[485]
to actually help children
[488]
you won't find any searchable hashtags
[490]
with typical q and on language on
[492]
instagram anymore
[493]
but because save the children isn't an
[495]
inherently harmful tagline
[496]
moderating it has proven particularly
[498]
difficult and tackling misinformation on
[501]
instagram can be harder than on facebook
[503]
since it's harder to train an algorithm
[505]
to recognize misleading text in
[506]
slideshow images
[507]
than it is to recognize text in facebook
[509]
posts or comments
[511]
the belief in q anon definitely falls
[513]
along a spectrum i don't think you can
[514]
say that everyone
[515]
that was how to say if the children
[517]
rally believes that hillary clinton
[518]
needs children it's the hysteria
[520]
it's the hysteria that grows and grows
[521]
and grows as you're going down that
[523]
rabbit hole
[523]
that could more than likely eventually
[526]
lead to you thinking that hillary
[527]
clinton needs children
[528]
cuon has really struck on something
[530]
clever in that
[531]
people get confused in their own way and
[534]
they fall down their own individual
[535]
rabbit holes that
[537]
that radicalize them according to their
[539]
own personality type
[541]
there are more than 20 candidates for
[542]
congress who have expressed support for
[544]
q anon
[545]
the real danger is that people don't
[547]
need to believe or even be aware of
[549]
the entirety of a conspiracy theory for
[552]
it to start influencing
[553]
their decisions
[570]
you