Kamala Harris looks to tax Wall Street to fund Medicare-for-all - YouTube

Channel: Fox Business

[0]
all right the first of two debates
[2]
kicking off today that's weird cuz you
[3]
have the first of a two day Fed meeting
[5]
at same time whatever shall we do a lot
[7]
of things going on
[8]
watching the candidates in how they take
[10]
advantage of this situation is going to
[12]
be very important and the money that
[13]
comes with it
[14]
they all have various ideas how they'll
[16]
pay for their very generous spending
[18]
plans Charlie gasps Reno has been
[20]
dissecting a lot of that particularly
[21]
Kamala Harris is made from Medicare for
[23]
oil which is being paid for attacks on
[25]
Wall Street and I've been speaking with
[27]
traders and investors over the last
[29]
couple days as this thing is taking
[31]
shape and I'll tell you a tweet I put
[33]
out yesterday really touched a nerve big
[35]
because when you really come down to it
[37]
you have to you know forget about
[39]
whether you like Kamala Harris or
[41]
dislike her but let's look at our tax
[42]
plan it is essentially a transaction tax
[45]
it is not saying JP Morgan bank of
[48]
America Goldman Sachs you pay more money
[51]
it is taxing individuals who trade
[55]
buying or selling yeah who are those
[57]
individuals who trade well there are a
[61]
lot of retirees who trade there are a
[63]
lot there are some average people who
[65]
trade their our pension funds who trade
[68]
right pension funds who hold the who
[71]
invest the the savings of of teachers
[74]
and retirement savings of teachers and
[75]
firemen and cops there are mutual funds
[78]
that trade okay
[79]
average people my mother-in-law out in
[82]
Queens is in him that owns a mutual fund
[84]
trust me she's not rich okay what are
[87]
you cheap you don't help okay
[90]
high-frequency traders do trade a lot
[93]
and maybe but numbers she says are small
[97]
so what are you lining up you can't make
[100]
you can't make your your your you can't
[103]
make your your bones on just a HFT ky4
[106]
is your trade so the real issue here is
[108]
whether this is a tax on Wall Street or
[111]
attacks on a phantom tax on the
[114]
individual and I would say every listen
[117]
just because you're in a mutual fund
[118]
doesn't mean you don't pay expenses
[120]
right if they market I think they're
[122]
called 10 B 5 charges you pay for those
[125]
charges smoothy's percentage are they
[127]
they add up so so is it your sense that
[131]
people you talk to be on Wall Street
[132]
that
[133]
it's it's going to be prohibitive that
[135]
investors who were priya klein to sell a
[137]
stock buy a stock mutual funds here's
[139]
the american will think twice here's the
[141]
impact it'll it could dry up liquidity
[143]
horse trading into dark pools overseas
[146]
whatever where you can hide the trades
[148]
it does it is gonna have an impact on
[150]
the average investor because that
[153]
investor will in some ways pay for this
[155]
it is and and and here's the other thing
[159]
which most people which it's kind of
[161]
burying the lede here no one knows how
[163]
much money you're getting out of this
[164]
this is a it starts out small tenth the
[166]
person will just sort of like the
[168]
value-added tax in europe start out
[170]
small until you figure out you can't pay
[172]
for this medicare for all for this which
[173]
is a whole other story whether we should
[175]
have medicare for for all which is i'm
[177]
just saying that this is a slippery
[179]
slope
[180]
she's gonna come or was he doing it too
[182]
it could be yeah he has a variation
[184]
variation but their argument is it's
[187]
pennies on the dollar not even and
[189]
there's Charlie guess Breno to say it's
[191]
more onerous you're great sell that to
[194]
the American people and by the way when
[195]
the stock market goes down 5,000 points
[197]
because liquidity is starting to dry up
[200]
people aren't trading you think that
[201]
this would do that it could be it really
[204]
well I mean listen the markets go down
[206]
based on lots of reasons including
[208]
corporate earnings at the top of the
[209]
list if they're good they'll keep going
[212]
up but the market will be lower you know
[214]
at some degree because of this they will
[216]
be lower than it should have been you
[218]
know because of this because this is a
[219]
tax on trading and liquidity and markets
[223]
perform best when there's liquidity when
[225]
you can anytime you want to sell your
[228]
your your stock your IBM stock there's
[231]
someone gonna buy it it's gonna buy it
[232]
at a reasonable price
[233]
it's not gonna be bought with massive
[236]
spreads where there's trade relations
[238]
and this sort of stuff impedes that and
[241]
it's and here's the other thing I don't
[243]
think she can get enough money from this
[245]
I think it seems so small but again if
[247]
you're dealing in the trillions of
[249]
transactions over the course it may be
[251]
well Southern people will trade alright
[253]
listen what was the last time you tax
[255]
something that they do more of it I
[256]
remember the the the backhoe taxes right
[259]
remember those bonds were based on
[261]
tobacco eventually people just stopped
[262]
buying tobacco product the bonds went
[265]
into default are
[266]
fair enough