The GOP Balanced Budget Plan - What's The Catch? - YouTube

Channel: The Young Turks

[0]
House Republicans have revealed their budget guidelines their blueprint for the next year
[5]
and it is a nightmare a nightmare combined with a fantasy it's like they've gone off
[10]
to Oz and now they're surrounded everything they could possibly y want that is the budget
[15]
that they have put across a budget that will never become law it will never be acted on
[20]
in the way that they hope that it will and look by the time next week at the end of next
[24]
week when it's finally voted on both the House version and the Senate version will have gone
[28]
over it in detail in multiple different ways today I want to introduce you to some of the
[32]
ridiculous policy prescriptions in this budget proposal it's being pushed by House Budget
[38]
Committee Chairman Tom Price and as I said it is complete fantasy so here are some of
[44]
general guidelines and specific proposals in it House Republicans say that it would
[48]
reach a $13 billion surplus in 2024 and a $33 billion surplus in 2025 that sounds great
[56]
overall by the way it would limit overall spending to something like 1.077 trillion
[60]
dollars as a ceiling it does reach those surplus though by projecting that increased economic
[66]
growth according to its policy prescriptions will generation $147 billion in additional
[70]
tax revenue for the government over the next 10 years this is dynamic scoring which mean
[75]
that rather than having the CBO actually look at what the bill with actually do they get
[81]
to instruct the CBO to interpret it in particular way to say look we're assuming certain things
[86]
about how this will effect economic growth which is ridiculous you can't OK just say
[92]
that it will triple the size of the economy why not just say that that's not how budgets
[95]
are actually scored that's not how we organize budget legislation it does not itemize actual
[103]
cuts that it says it will make but it says it would reduce $400 billion in spending from
[107]
Ryan's budgets they're talking about Paul Ryan who'd done previous budgets for the Republicans
[112]
there would be cuts coming from mandatory spending consolidating programs streamlining
[117]
regulations and eliminating waste fraud and abuse according to the report that's what
[122]
they say every time so understand that when they come out and they're going to be say
[126]
for the next two weeks that have balanced the budget despite the fact that we're going
[130]
to be throwing all of this extra money at the military we've balanced the budget they've
[133]
balanced the budget using two complete and utter tricks one dynamic scoring just making
[139]
up fake economic growth that's going to happen and two saying that we're going we're going
[144]
to eliminate waste and fraud and abuse which they don't want at all they love the tax fraud
[149]
that's currently going that has been going for decades in this country they're not actually
[152]
going to eliminate it so that's two little magic tricks they're playing the budget includes
[157]
$90 billion for the Defense Department's war funding account known as the overseas contingency
[162]
operations fund which falls outside the base budget and has been used to carry out the
[166]
wars in Iraq and Afghanistan so they're going to be throwing massive amounts of additional
[171]
military spending more than the military is actually requesting but Obama was already
[176]
giving them tons of money they're going to be giving more and then outside of that they
[179]
have this additional sort of piggy bank that they can use and if you give them the billions
[184]
of dollars they're going to find a way to use it sure but it's ridiculous to say that
[188]
we're going to be making all of these cuts which you're going to see soon and then we're
[192]
just going to give more money than the military is even asking for it insane the world that
[197]
we live in when it comes to the budgetary priorities of the United States now importantly
[201]
it doesn't touch Social Security which is an area that I guess one way that they didn't
[206]
go absolutely insane in this proposal but it does propose that a bipartisan commission
[210]
study the entitlement programs problems and then submit proposals to congress so they're
[216]
not willing to say we're going to cut Social Security just yet but they do want somebody
[221]
to come up with a way to cut Social Security I have a feeling that they will find a way
[225]
in the end it was partially privatize Medicare and convert Medicaid into block grants repeal
[231]
the popular Medicaid expansion offered through ObamaCare he argues that the Obama Care repeal
[235]
would save more than $2 trillion again that's effectively just made up and so that's another
[241]
way that they're saying they're going to save all this money that they will not actually
[245]
save really fast before I continue with that so here's what's going to actually happen
[250]
in the real world if they theoretically did get this budget to actually be passed then
[254]
over the next ten years you would see massively increased deficits you would see tons more
[260]
money added to the national debt and then in 8 or 12 or 16 years when the country is
[266]
like this is ridiculous the economy is catering because of the economic irresponsibility of
[271]
the Republicans then they'll elect a Democrat the economy will be in shambles the deficits
[275]
will be super high and they'll say oh it's that Democrats fault that's exactly what they
[280]
did with Obama and that's exactly what they're trying to set up with this budgetary fantasy
[285]
that they have here by the way the whole repealing Obamacare they obviously they don't actually
[292]
offer up any alternative you're not going to be surprised to find out that and they
[296]
specifically add language in this budget proposal that would allow Obamacare to be repealed
[301]
with a simple majority vote of course they have to make it as simple as possible by the
[306]
way also and so when I say that this is a fantasy land and it's like them going through
[310]
Willy Wonka's chocolate factory and choosing all of the budgetary candies that they like
[313]
the most get a lot of this the house budget would also repeal much of Obama's 2010 law
[318]
regulating Wall Street financial firms it would cut food stamps significantly converting
[322]
them into a state flexibility fund to be administered by state governments so any kind of federal
[327]
responsibility for that is going to be gone which means that states can then decide to
[331]
completely cut it or massively cut it if they want to it would cut the size of Pell Grants
[336]
the popular federal financial aid programs for higher education one of the few ways that
[340]
education is remotely affordable for many Americans is these Pell Grants which already
[346]
are not keeping up with the rise in tuition and cost of living for college students they're
[350]
going to further cut that so food stamps gone financial regulation of Wall Street regulation
[354]
which is already too weaksauce gone Pell Grants are going to be gone and then just to sum
[359]
it up if you have any I guess last idea that maybe the Republicans care at all about the
[366]
regular person the regular American citizen over the next decade the blueprint proposes
[371]
raising defense spending by a total of $387 billion dollars and cutting non defense spending
[376]
by $759 billion so that's what they like our military already takes up more money than
[386]
I mean watch Newsroom like our next ten allies combined we spend more than is conceivable
[392]
by a rational brain we could accomplish everything we want with our military and still massively
[399]
cut the military theoretically but no it's already crazy high and it's going to get higher
[404]
over the next 10 years and by the way I mean with spending more money on that we got to
[409]
cut money somewhere and so they're going to be cutting it from all the few remaining that
[413]
we actually help out regular people the Pell Grants the food stamps there's going to be
[417]
tax changes in there which are going to screw over especially poor people Rubio's tax which
[422]
we'll be talking about soon raises the minimum tax bracket for the poorest American's by
[427]
50% while cutting taxes for people making over $200,000 this is what the Republicans
[435]
actually want for this country now is it actually going to happen no it's not going to happen
[439]
the Senate is going to come out with their version tomorrow I believe Mike Enze the Senate
[443]
Budgetary Chairman is going to come out with his they're going to talk about it for a week
[447]
mark it up combine the differences and all that and then vote on it it's fantasy I don't
[451]
know what the Democratic counter proposal is going to be I don't know what Obama is
[456]
going to do but there is absolutely no way that American can weather a budget like this
[460]
it's a fantasy it needs to be destroyed