Someday: The long fight for a female president - YouTube

Channel: Vox

[1]
INTERVIEWER: For all practical purposes, do you think a woman in the United States today
[6]
can actually be nominated on the ticket as president?
[10]
CHISHOLM: Because how dare you?
[13]
Have you forgotten that you are a woman?
[16]
SCHROEDER: If I had to say that all of America was ready, uhhhh no.
[21]
It’s not quite there yet.
[23]
CLINTON: Well this isn’t the party I planned, but I sure like the company.
[30]
INTERVIEWER: For all practical purposes, do you think a woman in the United States today
[31]
can actually be nominated on the ticket as president?
[32]
CHISHOLM: Because how dare you? Have you forgotten that you are a woman?
[33]
SCHROEDER: If I had to say that all of America was ready, uhhhh no. It’s not quite there
[34]
yet.
[35]
CLINTON: Well this isn’t the party I planned, but I sure like the company.
[36]
CLINTON: Now, I -- I know -- I know we have still not shattered that highest and hardest
[39]
glass ceiling, but some day someone will and hopefully sooner than we might think right
[46]
now.
[47]
MARGARET CHASE SMITH: There are those that make the contention that no woman should ever
[58]
dare to aspire to the White House, that this is a man’s world and that it should be kept
[65]
that way.
[67]
Margaret Chase Smith was the first Republican woman to run for president. She was a three-term
[71]
senator from Maine.
[72]
QUESTION: Who will be your running mate?
[73]
SMITH: None of the announced candidates have indicated any desire.
[74]
The day she announced, Washington Post columnists had already dubbed her campaign “non-serious.”
[77]
NATIVIDAD: The idea of a woman running for President of the United States wasn’t taken
[82]
seriously
[83]
Smith had spent the previous 24 years in Congress, initially elected to her husband’s seat
[87]
when he died.
[88]
But around the country, opportunities for women to enter male-dominated jobs were shrinking
[93]
after WW2.
[94]
NATIVIDAD: Rosie the Riveter had to go back home and start making dinner again. Women
[99]
gained traction, if you will, as workers, but then the men came back and there was an
[103]
understanding that they had to be employed.
[106]
O’NEILL: There was no organized women’s movement there to fight for them and this
[111]
is why the 1950s women’s rights went into a deep, really a deep crater.
[115]
DEBBIE REYNOLDS: Don’t you think marriage is just the most important thing in the world?
[119]
I mean a woman isn’t really a woman at all until she’s married and had children.
[123]
This was the era when the National Weather Service started giving hurricanes female names
[128]
and when airline stewardesses were fired when they turned 32.
[132]
For two decades, there was little change in the percentage of Americans who said they
[135]
would vote for a female presidential candidate if she was qualified.
[139]
That stagnation coincided with a broad effort to reassert traditional gender roles as part
[144]
of the ideological battles of the Cold War.
[146]
LEAVE IT TO BEAVER: They say a woman’s place is in the home and I suppose as long as she’s in
[151]
the home, she might as well be in the kitchen.
[152]
It had become popular for Freudian psychologists to blame working women for society’s ills.
[157]
NARRATOR: Everywhere children with working parents are being left without adequate supervision
[162]
or restraint.
[163]
FARNHAM: Catastrophic social forces have propelled American women away from femininity and into
[171]
careers a terrific cost to themselves and society.
[175]
Political operatives were able to leverage these trends to end the career of Minnesota
[178]
Congresswoman Coya Knutson in 1958.
[181]
She lost her re-election after they arranged for her estranged husband to publish a letter
[186]
asking for her to come home and care for their family.
[189]
And those women who somehow managed to get a law degree at that time faced open discrimination
[194]
when they graduated.
[195]
SANDRA DAY O’CONNOR: I called at least 40 of those firms asking for an interview and
[202]
not one of them would give me an interview. I was a woman and they said we don’t hire
[208]
women.
[209]
When the women’s liberation movement got up and running in the late 60s and in the
[211]
70s, the early priorities were fighting job discrimination and securing equal rights in
[216]
the law.
[217]
During this time, the number of women in Congress barely changed, but the Democratic party saw
[221]
a female presidential candidate in Shirley Chisholm, a Congresswoman from New York.
[226]
CHISHOLM: I stand before you today as a candidate for the Democratic nomination for presidency
[233]
of the United States of America.
[236]
O’NEILL: She was a truly feminist, anti-racist lawmaker.
[243]
CHISHOLM: I believe we are intelligent enough to recognize the talent, energy and dedication
[249]
which all Americans, including women and minorities have to offer.
[254]
Chisholm was one of the prominent feminists who created the National Women’s Political
[257]
Caucus in 1971, with the goal of electing more women to Congress. In response, the Secretary
[262]
of State at the time reportedly joked with President Nixon that the women resembled “a
[268]
burlesque.”
[269]
By 1977, fully half of the country still agreed with the statement that most men are better
[274]
suited emotionally for politics than most women.
[277]
INTERVIEWER: You both have combined, it seems to me very successfully, marriage and politics.
[282]
What do you say to people that say the two are incompatible. How have you done this?
[287]
MINK: Well I think that’s probably the most offensive question that’s ever asked, because
[294]
I truly believe that men and women are equal. And I’ve never heard anyone ask a man, how
[301]
has it been on your family? I mean, it’s seldom asked.
[304]
MALCOLM: We had made very little progress from the dawn of the women’s movement. In
[308]
fact Democratic women had lost seats in the House.
[312]
Nevertheless, in 1984 women’s groups convinced the Democratic presidential candidate to choose
[316]
a Congresswoman as his running mate.
[318]
MONDALE: I looked for the best vice president and I found her in Gerry Ferraro.
[326]
NATIVIDAD: Oh, I thought our lives would change.
[331]
FERRARO: If we can do this, we can do anything.
[339]
MALCOLM: Women were coming out in record numbers, and they would bring their children and hold
[346]
their babies up, and show their daughters what it would be like to have a woman running
[351]
for vice president.
[352]
NATIVIDAD: Everything will be different after this. It wasn’t.
[356]
MEET THE PRESS: Geraldine Ferraro, the Democrat who wants to be vice president. Ms. Ferraro,
[362]
could you push the nuclear button?
[364]
BUSH: Let me help you with the difference, Ms. Ferraro, between Iran and the embassy
[370]
in Lebanon.
[371]
FERRARO: Let me just say, first of all, that I almost resent, Vice President Bush, your
[375]
patronizing attitude that you have to teach me about foreign policy.
[379]
The majority of women, like the majority of men, voted for the popular incumbent president
[384]
that year.
[385]
It would be more than two decades before one of the major parties nominated another woman
[389]
for vice president.
[393]
In the 1980s women caught up to men in college enrollment, and they’d surpassed them in
[397]
voter turnout rates in presidential elections.
[400]
But the public and the press still didn’t know what to make of women seeking elected
[404]
office, as Congresswoman Patricia Schroeder found when she briefly considered running
[408]
for president in the 1988 election.
[410]
SCHROEDER: The first thing you always get is, ‘Well you don’t look presidential.’
[416]
My answer was always ‘I know that. There’s never been a president of the United States
[419]
that looks like me. I find that regrettable. But, you know.’
[425]
O’NEILL: When she announced that she was ending or suspending her campaign — it was
[430]
clear that she was not going to win in the primaries — you know, she became emotional
[433]
just for a moment.
[435]
SCHROEDER: I could not figure out how to run and not be separated from those I serve. There
[443]
must be a way but I haven’t figured it out yet.
[448]
O’NEILL: She was roundly pilloried. ‘Oh, this proves it, women are too soft. Women
[454]
are too emotional.’ And you know, the impact on Congresswoman Schroeder was not very great.
[462]
I’ve met her, she’s an an amazingly tough, optimistic, extraordinary person. The impact
[467]
was on bystander women who might have been thinking that they might want to run.
[472]
Women running for office faced a double bind. They had to appear tough enough to lead, but
[477]
if they were too tough or too confident, they violated norms about how women are supposed
[481]
to behave.
[482]
This is how the Washington Post described Barbara Mikulski after she became one of two
[486]
women in the Senate in 1986.
[488]
MALCOLM: There was one Republican, Nancy Kassebaum, and Senator Mikulski, and 98 men.
[495]
Malcolm’s new fundraising organization, EMILY’s List had helped make Mikulski a
[499]
credible candidate. Together they set out to bring more Democratic women to Congress,
[503]
and they got a boost when law professor Anita Hill was called to testify about a Supreme
[508]
Court Nominee.
[509]
NEWS 4: Clarence Thomas called Anita Hill a liar. Hill says Thomas sexually harassed
[512]
her and she passed a lie detector test.
[515]
O’NEILL: The all-male panel doing the hearings for Clarence Thomas decided to simply attack
[523]
her.
[524]
HEFLIN: Are you a scorned woman?
[526]
SIMPSON: I would think that these things with you describe are so repugnant that you would
[532]
never have talked to him again, and that is the most contradictory and puzzling thing
[538]
for me.
[539]
O’NEILL: What Anita Hill was describing was absolutely resonant with what so many
[545]
women had experienced in their own lifetime. They knew she was telling the truth.
[550]
MALCOLM: Women were furious. And when they found out there were only two women in the
[554]
Senate, they decided they were going to do something about it. And they did.
[558]
CBS NEWS: They’re calling it the Year of the Woman. What impact will it have on Congress?
[563]
JORDAN: And what we see today is simply a dress rehearsal for the day and time we meet
[569]
in convention to nominate madam president.
[572]
O’NEILL: For the first time in the United States House of Representatives, the number
[575]
of women increased to fully 10 percent.
[576]
The 1992 election brought in 24 congresswomen and 4 female senators.
[580]
MIKULSKI: Some women spend their life looking out the window for Prince Charming. I’ve
[584]
been waiting six years for new women to come to the United States Senate.
[589]
MOSELEY-BRAUN: And I was telling the students at the time that eight women had been elected
[593]
to the United States Senate. And one little girl looked at me and said, ‘Is that all?’
[598]
Her universe, her world showed her the possibilities and that is the progress that we have achieved.
[608]
While women continued to make slow but steady gains in Congress, lack of money and party
[613]
support prevented female candidates from making credible bids at a presidential nomination.
[617]
DOLE: I think what we’ve done is pave the way for the person who will be the first woman
[623]
president.
[624]
MOSELEY-BRAUN: We are committed to opening up our democracy. We will get there one day.
[629]
So when Hillary Clinton entered the 2008 primaries as the presumptive front-runner, it was utterly
[636]
unprecedented.
[637]
COURIC: If it’s not you, how disappointed will you be?
[640]
CLINTON: Well, it will be me.
[641]
Like Congressional candidates in the 80s and 90s, Clinton’s strategy was to campaign
[646]
as any man would, emphasizing strength and minimizing gender.
[649]
O’NEILL: Her advisers were absolutely determined to downplay that.
[653]
CAMPAIGN AD: If we have the will, she has the strength. If we have the conviction, she
[658]
has the experience.
[659]
MALCOLM: It was a 1990s strategy, because certainly in the early days, that’s  what
[660]
we had to do with candidates.
[661]
O’NEILL: I think it started changing at the end of the primaries in 2008.
[662]
CLINTON: But I am a woman and, like millions of women, I know there are still barriers
[671]
and biases out there, often unconscious.
[675]
Her attempt to run a genderless campaign didn’t keep sexism out of the election.
[680]
CARLSON: That is so perfect, because I have often said when she comes on television, I
[686]
involuntarily cross my legs.
[688]
CAFFERTY: She morphed into a scolding mother
[689]
BARNICLE: Looking like everyone’s first wife standing outside a probate court
[693]
by the time of her concession speech, Clinton seemed to recognize that her supporters didn’t
[698]
want to ignore gender.
[699]
O’NEILL: I had managed to somehow get on a platform so I could actually see her from
[703]
very far away. And what was really striking to me is I’m looking around and many, many,
[708]
many women in tears.
[710]
CLINTON: Although we weren't able to shatter that highest, hardest glass ceiling this time,
[717]
thanks to you, it's got about 18 million cracks in it, and the light is shining through like
[735]
never before, filling us all with the hope and the sure knowledge that the path will
[737]
be a little easier next time.
[739]
Eight years later, Clinton’s openly campaigned on her experiences as a woman.
[742]
CLINTON: Look, I’m not asking people to vote for me because I’m a woman. But I think
[747]
if you vote for somebody on the merits, one of my merits is I’m a woman and I think
[751]
that makes a big difference in this world.
[754]
Oddly, the first woman to come close to the presidency faced an openly sexist opponent.
[758]
TRUMP: You know, you could see there was blood coming out of her eyes, blood coming out of
[763]
her...wherever.
[764]
CNN: “Look at that face,” he cries, “Would anybody vote for that? Can you imagine that?
[768]
The face of our next president? I mean she’s a woman. I’m not supposed to say bad things
[772]
but really, folks, come on, are we serious?”
[774]
HOLT: Earlier this month you said she doesn’t have, quote, a presidential look. She’s
[779]
standing here right now. What did you mean by that?
[781]
TRUMP: She doesn’t have the look. She doesn't have the stamina.
[785]
But women have never voted as a unified block.
[787]
MSNBC: The exit polls, sir, shows that Trump did better with women than expected. For example,
[791]
white women ages 45-64. Trump won by 19 points there.
[796]
So how much longer will it be?  That depends on how many women are in the pipeline.
[800]
LAWLESS:  We just don’t have that many women in the Senate or in governors’ mansions
[804]
and those are the two most likely paths to the presidency.
[806]
The focus on the presidential race can obscure the fact that women who run for Congress and
[811]
governor are just as likely as men to win. The problem is fewer women are running.
[815]
LAWLESS: We identified a national sample of lawyers, business leaders, educators and political
[821]
activists. And across the board there was about a 16 point gender gap in political ambition.
[827]
They’ve done this survey twice and the gap didn’t shrink between 2001 and 2011.
[832]
When asked to assess their qualifications for public office, the women rated themselves
[835]
lower than men.
[836]
HALEY: We second-guess ourselves. We always try to say well what if this happens or what
[841]
if I’m not ready or what if I don’t know enough. And that’s where women hold themselves
[845]
back.
[846]
The confidence gap between men and women is a broad societal problem, but there’s one
[850]
easy way to continue working toward gender parity in politics.
[853]
LAWLESS: Women are less likely than men to be recruited or encouraged to run for office.
[858]
And when women and men get that encouragement, get that boost, they’re far more likely
[862]
to throw their hats into the ring.
[863]
MALCOLM: There’s a lot of ways we can find support for you, but we need your leadership
[868]
and your intelligence and your hard work to make this democracy work. So think about it.
[872]
Maybe you should be running for office.
[873]
NATIVIDAD: All the rights that we have are tenuous. It depends on administration, it
[876]
depends on current politicians. It depends on memory. So be vigilant. Be the voice for
[882]
change. Don’t just be a recipient of it.
[885]
CLINTON: You will have successes and setbacks, too. This loss hurts. But please, never stop
[893]
believing that fighting for what’s right is worth it.